Pagan Roots of Western Civilization
Recently I found myself riding through the German countryside while autumn sunlight cut across the fields in long and severe beams. A friend beside me remarked with great certainty that Christianity is the foundation of civilization and that without it the entire edifice of the West would crumble into dust. His tone carried the confidence of a man repeating something he had been taught rather than something he had truly examined. I answered by pointing to ancient Rome. The empire that set the standard for administration, law, architecture, and martial spirit did so long before a single bishop ever presided over a council. Rome did not require the Sermon on the Mount to raise its legions nor did it lean on the prophets of the Levant to build aqueducts, bridge continents, or order its dominion.
The actual roots of Western civilization lie not in Jerusalem or the sun blasted deserts of the Levant but in the Hellenic and Italic worlds. Athens taught us inquiry, courage in debate, civic participation, and the high beauty of rational order. Rome taught us discipline, law, hierarchy, and the stern virtue of duty. The Western mind is primarily shaped by these pagan inheritances rather than the revelations of Sinai. When modern men speak of reason, public virtue, individual excellence, and the relentless pursuit of mastery they are not echoing Hebrew prophets. They are echoing Pericles and Caesar.
This raises a difficult point for many who have inherited the modern assumption that Christianity is the wellspring of civilization. No great civilization has ever arisen out of Abrahamic texts. The Israelites produced a people with powerful traditions and tenacious identity yet they never built anything that resembles what we would call a civilization. There was no grand urbanism, no industrial engine, no sweeping legal code that shaped continents, no philosophical school that reshaped the human mind, and no significant art that might point man to a higher call. Their strengths lay in tribal durability and religious cohesion rather than the expansive creativity that marks civilizational ascent.
Rome by contrast is the very epitome of civilization. Its marble roads ran like arteries across the ancient world. Its legions became the gold standard of organized force. Its legal principles endured through the fall of empires and shaped the codes of Europe for centuries. Its social imagination reached into every domain of life. When we use the word civilization today we do so with an unspoken reference to Rome. That Rome was decidedly pagan. Its pantheon reflected cosmic order. Its ruler cult expressed political unity. Its public life assumed that the world was intelligible and could be governed by human reason and human courage. Rome also accepted without apology the natural hierarchy among men. It believed that excellence justified authority and that rank flowed from merit, courage, and accomplishment rather than from abstract claims of equality. This worldview stands far closer to the Hellenic ideal than to the inherited religiosity of the desert.
The Middle Ages are often presented as a Christian era, yet in truth, they reveal a deep pagan imprint. Christianity spread across northern Europe and managed to dominate the outward institutions of culture, but it never erased the pagan substratum of the peoples it converted. The medieval church adapted preexisting festivals, absorbed regional spirits into saint cults, and blessed holy sites that had been sacred to older gods long before building its monasteries and cathedrals atop them. What is most striking is how thoroughly medieval Catholicism clothed itself in pagan imagery. Cathedrals are filled with symbols that would have been entirely at home in a pagan temple. Serpents, lions, green men, zodiac signs, and sun wheels adorn the stone facades. One can see satyrs carved upon the very doors of the great cathedral at Cologne. Gothic arches rise with the same bold aspiration that once animated Roman basilicas.
Much of medieval piety is simply paganism covered with a Christian veneer. The rituals echo the older rhythms of agrarian Europe. The saints often occupy roles once held by local deities. The Virgin sits upon a throne in imagery that mirrors Isis with Horus upon her lap. When we examine cathedrals, reliquaries, tapestries, and manuscripts we find an artistic language far more indebted to pagan Europe than to anything described in biblical or judaic scripture.
The Renaissance reveals this pagan impulse in an even more explicit manner. It is a conscious revival of classical ideals. It is a movement that sought to reclaim a lost inheritance rather than to extend Christian doctrine. Renaissance thinkers turned away from medieval, theological scholasticism and reached back to Plato, Livy, Cicero, Vitruvius and the entire spirit of antiquity. They believed that European greatness would be rekindled by returning to pagan roots. Their art confirms this. Look to the frescoes and statues of the period. They are populated with Apollo, Venus, Jupiter and heroic forms that celebrate the beauty and power of the human body.
The Renaissance therefore stands as a great awakening for pagan European heritage. It is a rejection of the values of meekness, self abasement, and world denying piety that had permeated the medieval church. It replaces them with vigor, proportion, reason and the exaltation of human potential. The pagan imagination rises again in the domes, columns and mathematical harmonies of the age. Michelangelo did not sculpt saints as trembling penitents. He sculpted them as titanic men. His David stands like a young Greek god poised in perfect tension. This is not Christian humility. It is pagan assertion.
The Reformation emerges in opposition to this pagan current. It represents a deliberate turn back toward the Bible. Reformers accused the Catholic Church of having been corrupted by paganism. They charged that saints were but renamed gods, that rituals had strayed from Scripture, and that beauty itself had seduced the faithful away from pure doctrine. The spirit of the Reformation demanded austerity, iconoclasm and a return to the stark world of the text. In doing so it created a deeper divide within Europe between its pagan cultural inheritance and its biblical conscience.
The Enlightenment then arrives as yet another attempt to look back to pagan roots and to cast off the strictures of the Reformation. It exalts empiricism, human reason, the scientific method, secular governance, and individual liberty. These ideals are pagan in spirit even when their advocates claimed modern originality. The great minds of the Enlightenment were captivated by Greece and Rome. They saw in the ancient world a model for understanding both nature and man, and they inherited from the pagan world a recognition that nature itself stands as the ultimate law giver. Pagan societies understood that laws are not invented by prophets but discovered in the structure of the cosmos. The Enlightenment therefore revived not only classical methods of inquiry but also the older conviction that legitimacy arises from conformity to nature's order rather than obedience to revelation.
Consider the intellectual life of elite colonial Americans. They embodied Enlightenment ideals and built their world upon them. Their libraries confirm this. Plutarch's Lives was more likely to be found in their homes than the Bible. They read Roman history to learn statecraft. They read Greek philosophy to learn virtue. They looked to Sparta and Rome for examples of courage, civic order, military strength and the disciplined life. Though they retained a cultural veneer of Christianity they did not use Jerusalem as their model for a republic. They used Athens and Rome.
Even so some elements of Judeo Christian thought entered the Enlightenment by way of cultural habit. Universalism and binary moral attitudes concerning good and evil crept in. Yet these did not define the movement. They dulled the edges but they did not form the foundation. The engine of the Enlightenment remained pagan. It trusted human reason. It trusted inquiry. It trusted that the world was shaped by laws that could be understood by disciplined minds.
America ultimately was built by men who looked far more to Rome and Greece than to Jerusalem. Washington admired the Roman ideal of the citizen soldier. Jefferson patterned his intellectual life after the classical tradition. Adams viewed the republic through the lens of Roman history. These men lived in a world where the Bible was culturally important yet they did not use it as the blueprint for the new nation. They studied Roman virtue, civic discipline, and the stern lessons of antiquity to guide their decisions.
The symbols of early America confirm this pagan lineage. The architecture of the Capitol. The columns of the White House. The Roman eagles. The very language of the founding documents reflects classical thought. The founders believed that liberty flourished when men cultivated reason and virtue and they believed that the classical world provided the strongest guide to these ends.
For these reasons the claim that Christianity is the foundation of Western civilization collapses under scrutiny. Christianity shaped parts of our moral imagination yet the civilizational achievements that define the West arise from pagan soil. Our institutions of governance, our methods of inquiry, our concept of civic life, our martial traditions, and our aspiration toward greatness descend from Athens and Rome. The Christian story is only one thread of a broader tapestry and it is not the thread that formed the loom.
Featured viewing:
